Crackdown Proposed to Prevent Illegal Immigrants From Obtaining Medicare
By ROBERT PEAR
MARCH 3, 2014 - New York Times
WASHINGTON — The Obama
administration is planning new steps to prevent people in the country illegally
from obtaining Medicare after finding that tens of thousands were improperly
receiving benefits.
In President Obamafs budget for
2015, to be unveiled on Tuesday, and in new regulations, the administration
proposes to remove illegal immigrants from the Medicare rolls and explicitly
require citizenship or lawful presence in the United States as a condition of
getting Medicare.
Under a 1996 law, the
administration said, immigrants are generally ineligible to receive federal
benefits if they are gunlawfully present in the United States.h But, officials
said, many illegal immigrants have received benefits because the Medicare agency
did not update its rules or policies to carry out the restrictions imposed by
Congress.
In his budget, expected to total
roughly $3.8 trillion, Mr. Obama steers clear of structural changes in social
welfare programs, which make up about 60 percent of the budget. But he proposes
substantial savings in Medicare, including cuts in payments for nursing homes
and home health agencies.
Although Medicare costs have been
growing slowly in recent years, the number of beneficiaries is expected to grow
35 percent in a decade, to 70 million in 2024. And the cost of Medicare drug
benefits is expected to shoot up to $170 billion, from $70 billion this
year.
The administration said its
proposal to have illegal immigrants ginvoluntarily disenrolledh would save at
least $67 million over five years, mainly by requiring private Medicare
Advantage plans and prescription drug plans to deny or revoke coverage for
people who are in the country illegally.
The inspector general at the
Department of Health and Human Services, Daniel R. Levinson, said Medicare had
improperly paid tens of millions of dollars a year to hospitals, doctors,
nursing homes and pharmacies that had provided services to illegal
immigrants.
Mr. Levinson found that the
Medicare agency and private Medicare plans were incorrectly treating people in
the country illegally as eligible for drug benefits and had done little to block
payment of their drug claims.
In response to the findings,
Marilyn B. Tavenner, the administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid
Services, said she would try to recoup some of the money. And she said that
Medicare computers would be instructed to deny claims for illegal immigrants
enrolled in the traditional Medicare program.
But nearly 30 percent of the 52
million Medicare beneficiaries are in private Medicare Advantage plans, not
traditional Medicare. And Medicarefs outpatient drug benefit is delivered
entirely by private insurers, subsidized by the government.
Jenny Rejeske, a health policy
analyst at the National Immigration Law Center, a legal advocacy group, said:
gTherefs no suggestion of fraud here. The real fraud in Medicare is by health
care providers. Payments for immigrants are just a drop in the bucket compared
with provider fraud.h
Medicare relies mainly on
information from Social Security to identify people in the country illegally.
Social Security obtains data from the Department of Homeland Security and other
federal agencies. Even if immigrants have worked in the United States and paid
taxes, Medicare is not supposed to pay their medical bills if they are not here
legally on the days they receive care.
The new White House budget
director, Sylvia Mathews Burwell, is highlighting ginvestments in the health
care work forceh to help treat millions of people expected to gain insurance
under the Affordable Care Act.
The presidentfs budget would
provide $5.2 billion over 10 years to train 13,000 new doctors, mainly primary
care physicians. Mr. Obama will also seek $4 billion to expand the National
Health Service Corps, increasing the number of its providers in underserved
areas by two-thirds, to 15,000, from 8,900.
Dr. Atul Grover, the chief
lobbyist at the Association of American Medical Colleges, welcomed the proposals
to increase the supply of doctors. But, he said, gThey could be offset by cuts
in Medicare support for graduate medical education.h The White House contends
that Medicare overpays teaching hospitals for treating sicker patients who
require specialized services.
Mr. Obama also wants to reduce
scheduled Medicare payments to nursing homes and home health agencies, which the
administration says have high profit margins on their Medicare business. In
addition, he would impose financial penalties on nursing homes that send large
numbers of Medicare patients to hospitals with preventable illnesses and
injuries.
The presidentfs budget also
includes a proposal to encourage nursing homes and home health agencies to
coordinate care for patients discharged from hospitals. Medicare would make a
single gbundled paymenth for post-hospital care of a patient lasting two or
three months. This is part of the administrationfs effort to move away from
paying providers separately for each service, officials said.
Mr. Obama also recycles a proposal
that has languished in Congress for several years, requiring drug companies to
provide additional discounts, or rebates, to Medicare for prescription drugs
bought by low-income beneficiaries. This proposal is strenuously opposed by drug
makers.